The boolean transfer flag went two commits ago because a one-sided verdict let
half a movement vanish and left the report unbalanced. This is what replaces
it: a [[transfer]] block names both legs, and only a matched pair is dropped
from the report -- both legs together, never one.
Legs pair within five days, nearest date first, and a transaction belongs to at
most one transfer, so the first definition to claim a leg keeps it, exactly as
the first matching rule keeps a tag. The pairing is derived state like the tags:
Engine.Link rewrites the whole transfers table from rules.toml, which is why
retag re-derives both halves of what that file decides, and why it runs over
the whole index rather than a filtered view -- pairing inside one would let a
movement count as a transfer in one report and not in another. An unmatched leg
is not a transfer and keeps counting, surfaced as a warning instead.
Within one currency the amount is the evidence and must be the exact opposite.
Across currencies it is not checked at all: there are no rates here, so the two
numbers are unrelated and the dates carry the pairing alone.
tolerance_pct is the one exception, per definition, for a route where the bank
takes a fee and the two statements genuinely disagree. It defaults to zero and
belongs on the one definition that charges; a global or default tolerance would
loosen every route that does not. The difference it admits is not forgiven --
the pair leaves the report entirely, so a fee hidden inside one would be
spending that appears nowhere. Pair.Fee is what left less what arrived, and
report.Excluded carries it out per currency alongside the legs. It counts only
pairs whose legs are both in view, for the same reason it counts legs and not
transfers: half a pair cannot say what the other half received.
The screens:
- 6 builds a definition against the index as you type, showing the pairs it
would form and the legs it would catch but leave unpaired. Six fields need
more room than the rule builder's four, so the form sheds its spacing, then
its hints, then the borders on unfocused fields.
- 7 lists every definition with what it pairs. Two counts, because they mean
different things: an unpaired leg is a definition doing something and not
finishing it, no pairs at all is dead weight. Tol names the tolerance, blank
where amounts must agree.
- 3 grows a (transfers) row under TOTAL, and a fees row beneath it, or the
report silently disagrees with the account balances.
Two things that are not part of transfers but are the same day's work:
- ls --uniq lists each account and description once, normalised the way a glob
sees them, which is the shape of "what still needs a rule?" -- fifty visits
to one shop are one pattern to write, not fifty rows to read.
- The rule builder's preview now filters to what the glob matches instead of
marking matches in a full list. The count carries the context the rows no
longer can: 2 of 7, measured against everything still in view.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Four removals in a row left both files describing things that are no longer
there, and one claim that was never true:
- The rules screen mock-up still had the transfer column, two commits after
that column went. The keys table listed 4 twice, once as a view switch and
once as the tagging row that replaced t; tagging is now a sentence saying
plainly that no key does it and why 4 is the answer.
- The rule builder mock-up was missing the account field entirely while the
prose below it described moving between four fields.
- glob was described as linear time with no backtracking. It is the two-pointer
wildcard match, which backtracks by design -- the branch is right there in
glob.go -- and is O(n*m) in the worst case. What it actually rules out is
exponential blowup on patterns like *a*a*a*.
- r on the rules screen was undocumented. It recounts against the index, which
is what an import makes stale; it does not re-read rules.toml, so an edit
made elsewhere still needs a restart.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The index is a cache. Everything in it is re-derived from the statements and
rules.toml, and has been since the last hand-set tags went, so keeping
machinery to nurse an old index through a schema change was paying for a
guarantee nothing needs. The ALTER TABLE lists, the dropped-column list and the
pragma_table_info reader are gone; Open applies the schema and returns.
What replaces it is a line in the release note: delete index.db and import
again. The two directions are not symmetric, which is worth knowing before
assuming something is broken. Removing a column leaves an older index working,
carrying the dead column and its data unread, because every statement here
names its columns -- that is why the drop half was never really load-bearing.
Adding a column the code reads breaks every command against an older index with
`no such column` until the file is deleted.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
A tag could come from two places: rules.toml, or the TUI's t key, which wrote
manual_tag with COALESCE(manual_tag, rule_tag) deciding the winner. That split
paid for itself in the first invariant of the codebase, in ClearOverrides and
the c key, in the * marker on the tag column, and in the one exception to a
disposable index -- a tag set by hand was the only thing in index.db that the
statements could not reproduce.
Now rules.toml decides every tag. The index is derived entirely from the
statements plus that file, so deleting it and re-importing gets back exactly
what was there, and retag has nothing to be careful of. Tagging a one-off means
writing a narrow rule on screen 4, which previews what the glob catches before
it is saved.
A manual tag in an existing index is dropped along with the column the first
time this build opens it, and those rows read as whatever the rules say, or as
untagged. TestManualTagSurvivesRetag guarded the invariant that has just been
removed; TestRetagRewritesEveryTag replaces it with the one that took its
place, and keeps Retag itself covered.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
A transfer was a second verdict carried alongside the tag: a boolean set by
transfer = true in a rule or by x in the TUI, kept in its own pair of rule_
and manual_ columns, whose one real effect was to hold the row out of the
report. The rest of it was display -- a T column in the transaction list, in
the rules screen and in money ls.
Money moved between your own accounts is now tagged like anything else and
counts like anything else. The leg leaving checking is an outflow and the leg
arriving in savings is an inflow, so a report over the whole data root roughly
nets out while one scoped to a single account or month does not. That is the
price of one verdict per transaction instead of two.
A rule now needs a tag, and one that set only transfer = true is refused by
number on load. A leftover transfer key beside a tag is ignored, as unknown
TOML keys always were, and an index built by an older binary drops both
columns when it is opened.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
counterparty was a structured field only nlb could fill honestly. revolut
and traderepublic invented one by running an IBAN-shaped regex over the
description they had just built, and the two spellings disagreed --
SI56 1234 5678 9012 345 against SI56123456789012345 -- so a literal rule
pattern that worked on one account silently matched nothing on another. It
is gone from the model, the index, the rule keys, ls --wide and the rules
screen. nlb now appends its IBAN column to the end of the description,
where the other two already keep theirs, so match = "*SI56*" works
everywhere. That changes those descriptions and with them their
fingerprints, so a statement overlapping an already-imported period will
re-add rather than dedupe those rows until the index is rebuilt. An index
built by an older binary drops the column when it is opened.
The index itself moves from .money/index.db up to index.db beside
rules.toml. Nothing looks in the old location, so an existing one has to be
moved by hand -- otherwise the tool quietly starts a fresh index and the
manual tags in the old file, the only thing statements cannot reproduce,
stay behind in it.
The csv and cmd parsers are gone along with the [csv] and [cmd] config they
carried. cmd shelled out to the Python extractors, which were ported to Go
and deleted, so it bridged to nothing; csv was a generic column-mapped
fallback that no account used, and between them they were the largest
configuration surface in the tool. A bank is now described in Go, where it
can be tested. The importer tests register their own three-column parser
rather than borrow a bank's, so they stay about the directory walk, dedupe
and per-file error reporting.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
A glob like *4412* says nothing about why it exists or who it catches, and
six months later neither does memory. Rules get an optional note: free text
that never takes part in matching, written as a TOML key rather than a
comment so it survives a round trip and can be shown back.
The rule builder grows a fourth field for it and the rules screen a last
column. Four fields spaced out are taller than a short window has room for,
so the form now drops its blank lines and then the hints on unfocused fields
before anything would run off the bottom.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Both fields are free text, and a slug or tag that is slightly wrong produces
a rule that silently catches nothing — or a second, near-identical tag. They
now complete against what already exists: accounts from the folders on disk
and the index, tags from every tag in use plus any named in rules.toml, so a
tag is completable from the moment a rule mentions it.
The completion is ghosted after the cursor and never committed until it is
accepted, so inventing a new tag still works. tab takes it and moves focus
only when there is nothing left to complete; ctrl+n/ctrl+p cycle an ambiguous
prefix, and the hint under the box says how many candidates are left.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Nothing showed whether a rule was still earning its place. The new screen, on
5, lists every rule in file order with the number of transactions it claims,
marking those that claim none.
The count comes from Engine.Usage, which counts by first match, so a rule
shadowed by an earlier one reports zero even though its glob matches. That is
the case worth catching: such a rule looks correct in isolation and can never
fire.
d removes the selected rule and p removes every unused one, each behind a y/n
confirmation since this rewrites a hand-maintained file. config.DeleteRules
edits rules.toml textually rather than re-serialising the parsed rules, so
comments and layout survive; a comment directly above a rule goes with it,
while one separated by a blank line is left as a heading. The result is
re-parsed before it replaces the file.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Writing a glob by hand meant guessing what it would catch, then running retag
to find out. The new screen, on 4, puts the glob, account and tag fields on
the left and every still-untagged description on the right, sorted
alphabetically and grouped by description with an occurrence count.
Matches are marked as the glob is typed, along with a count, so the effect of
a rule is visible before it is written. Enter appends it to rules.toml via
config.AppendRule, reloads the engine from disk and retags, so the rows it
caught leave the list immediately.
Rules are appended rather than prepended, keeping the precedence of anything
already in the file. Since the preview only lists transactions no existing
rule has tagged, it reflects that precedence for free.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
An account folder is only registered in the index by an import, so a freshly
configured account.toml produced an empty accounts table with nothing to say
why or what to do about it.
Each view now explains its own emptiness and names the key that resolves it,
distinguishing configured-but-not-imported from no-folders-at-all, and
telling apart a filter that matched nothing from having no data.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Running the tool from anywhere required either a --root flag or an exported
MONEY_ROOT. Read the data root from $XDG_CONFIG_HOME/money/config.toml
(~/.config/money/config.toml) instead, so it can be configured once.
Resolution order is --root, then $MONEY_ROOT, then the config file, then
~/money. A leading tilde in the config file is expanded, since no shell has
done it for us, and relative paths are made absolute.
The new "money config" subcommand prints the resolved root and which rule
chose it, which is the first thing to check when the tool reads the wrong
directory.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
A data directory holds one folder per account. Statements dropped into
those folders are parsed into a rebuildable SQLite index, categorised by
ordered glob rules in rules.toml, and browsed or hand-tagged in a Bubble
Tea TUI. Movements between the user's own accounts are marked as
transfers by the same rules and excluded from spending totals.
Manual tags and transfer marks are stored separately from the rule-derived
ones and always win, so editing rules.toml and re-running retag never
destroys hand edits.
Parsers are pluggable. Three are ported from the Python extractors they
replace -- nlb and traderepublic read PDFs via pdftotext -layout, revolut
reads the CSV export -- alongside a configurable-column CSV parser and a
cmd parser that shells out to an external script.
Both ports fix two latent bugs in the originals: the sign character class
rejected the typographic minus U+2212 that some PDF fonts emit, and NLB's
hardcoded continuation indent broke when pdftotext compressed runs of
spaces, so the threshold is now measured from the description column.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
nikolaandClaude Opus 5